This will be a three-hour-per-week course on natural language ontology

Time: Thursdays 14h-17h, sometimes Fridays 9h-12h

Start: September 17, 2026

Room: B122 Bâtiment Egger, Campus Schuman

Program

Sessions:

September 17, 2026: in person only

September 17:

Introduction; Ontology, Semantics, and Syntax

handout

• What is ontology, what is metaphysics?
• How does ontology relate to natural language?
• The ways of involvement of objects in the semantics of natural language: referential NPs, anaphora, implicit arguments, parameters of evaluation
• The importance of ontology for syntax and vice versa
• What sorts of linguistic data display the ontology implicit in natural language? A first look at the core-periphery distinction

Essential reading (further reading recommendations on the handout):

F. Moltmann, 2022: “Natural Language Ontology,“ Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Additional (optional) zoom meetings in September and October TBA soon

 

September 24: no class

October 1: no class

October 15: no class

online ZOOM meeting: https://univ-cotedazur.zoom.us/j/82421124087?pwd=kbieQTJJtbrPQQBarnbNF9Pkl0PrP4.1

 

October 22:

14h-16h

Class via ZOOM: https://univ-cotedazur.zoom.us/j/88000254402?pwd=zE1cPpSGiPD3n09KysmaRjlTpAiABN.1

Reference and Predication

handout

• Referential and other NPs
• The argument structure of predicates
• Predicates and properties
• The Fregean criterion of objecthood
• Potential problems for the view that referential NPs stand for objects

Recommended readings:

Davidson, D., 1967, “The Logical Form of Action Sentences,” in N. Rescher (ed.), The Logic

     of Decision and Action, Pittsburgh: Pittsburgh University Press, 81–95.

Fine, K., 1982, “Acts, Events and Things”, in Leinfellner, W. et al. (eds), Proceedings of the

      6th International Wittgenstein Symposium: Language and Ontology 8, Wien, Austria:

      H¨older-Pichler-Tempsky, 97–105.

Kim, J., 1976, “Events as Property Exemplifications”, in M. Brand and D. Walton (eds.),

     Action Theory, Dordrecht: Reidel, 310-326.

Link, G., 1983, “The Logical Analysis of Plurals and Mass Nouns,” in R. Baeuerle et al.

     (eds.), Semantics from Different Points of View, Berlin: Springer, 302-323.

 

October 23:

10h-12h

Class via ZOOM: https://univ-cotedazur.zoom.us/j/88000254402?pwd=zE1cPpSGiPD3n09KysmaRjlTpAiABN.1

Quantification

handout

• Quantification in logic and in natural language
• Quantification and ontological commitment
• Adverbial quantification
• ‘Non-nominal’ or special quantification

Recommended readings:

Moltmann, F. (2003):  'Nominalizing Quantifiers'. Journal of Philosophical Logic 32(5), 445-481

Nebel, J. (2019): ‘Hopes, Fears, and other grammatical scarecrows’. Philosophical Review,

Rieppel, M. (2016): ‘Being something: Properties and predicative quantification’. Mind 125(499).

Rosefeldt, T. (2008): ‘That’-clauses and non-nominal quantification’. Philosophical Studies, 137: 301–333.

 

October 29: semester break, no class

 

November 6 (Friday!):

10h-12h

Class via ZOOM: https://univ-cotedazur.zoom.us/j/88000254402?pwd=zE1cPpSGiPD3n09KysmaRjlTpAiABN.1

https://univ-cotedazur.zoom.us/j/88000254402?pwd=zE1cPpSGiPD3n09KysmaRjlTpAiABN.1 

Implicit arguments

handout

• Event semantics and its alternatives
• Other implicit arguments in the semantic literature
• Implicit arguments and light silent nouns
• Syntactic constraints on implicit arguments
• Implicit and explicit arguments: distinction in ontological commitment?

Recommended reading:

Davidson, D., 1967, “The Logical Form of Action Sentences,” in N. Rescher (ed.), The Logicof Decision and Action, Pittsburgh: Pittsburgh University Press, 81–95.

Moltmann, F. 2025. 'Events in Contemporary Semantics'. In James Bahoh, Marta Cassina, and Sergio Genovesi (eds): 21st-Century Philosophy of Events: Beyond the Analytic / Continental Divide. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.

 

November 12:

Tense and Modality

• Some basics of modal logic and modality in natural language
• Some basics of the semantics of tense
• Ontological commitment to possible worlds or situations: extending the range of criteria
• Ontological commitment to times

 

November 13:

Nonexistent objects

• Contexts of apparent referential NPs not standing for actual objects
• Existence predicates and intentional verbs
• Meinongianism and other approaches to apparent non-referring ‘referential’ NPs
• Restrictions on the availability of non-existent objects in the semantics

 

November 20:

Syntactic categories and ontology

• Ontological and grammatical categories
• Older view about the correlations of ontological and syntactic categories
• Crosslinguistic challenges
• Challenges from recent syntactic theories

 

November 21:

Parts and Wholes in Semantics 1

• Extensional mereology
• Plural reference

 

November 27

Parts and Wholes in Semantics 2

• Non-extensional mereology
• Abstract wholes

 

December 3:

Chomsky’s Challenges to Referentialist Semantics

• Phenomena of apparently incompatible copredication
• Semantic and ontological approaches to problems of co-predication
• What sorts of semantic values can and cannot be ‘real things’? 
• Conceptions of reality in philosophy
• The individuation of artifacts and related things

 

December 10:

The Ontological Core-Periphery Distinction

• The motivations for the core-periphery distinction
• How should the distinction bet characterized content-wise?
• How is the distinction linguistically grounded?
• How does the distinction relate to Chomsky’s core-periphery distinction?